Dubai Can’t Be Written Off Yet

Late last year, Dubai was crashing hard and the reason seemed obvious. Now The Economist says Dubai can’t be counted out:

The debt of Dubai’s government and government-controlled companies is about $80 billion. Almost $11 billion comes due this year (including interest) and $12.4 billion next. Nakheel alone must refinance a $3.52 billion bond in December and another worth 3.6 billion dirhams ($980m) five months later, according to EFG-Hermes, an Egyptian investment bank.

The rocks for Dubai’s breakwater have been provided by its neighbour Abu Dhabi. The wealthiest of the seven members of the United Arab Emirates (UAE), Abu Dhabi sits on 94% of the federation’s oil reserves. Through the central bank, it bought $10 billion of Dubai’s bonds, half of a proposed $20 billion issue. This bail-out, announced in February, has restored calm, as shown by the falling cost of insurance against default (see chart). The economy has shifted “from the crisis mood to the solution mood,” wrote Dubai’s ruler, Sheikh Muhammad bin Rashid al-Maktoum, in an online discussion with reporters on April 18th, his first in eight years.

…The restructuring of Dubai Inc has begun. Nakheel shed 15% of its staff in December and has continued to pare its numbers since. Sheikh Muhammad’s own Dubai Holding has also cut staff. “Last year, people would talk about how many houses they owned,” says one Dubai veteran. “Now, they talk about how many friends have lost their jobs.” Other economies benefit from automatic fiscal stabilisers as the unemployed stop paying taxes and start spending welfare benefits. The UAE suffers from an automatic destabiliser: 30 days after a foreigner loses his job, he loses his right to stay. Once they leave, Dubai’s ex-expats will spend nothing in the economy they leave behind.

…Dubai lives in a good neighbourhood, however. Abu Dhabi, the next-door emirate, has 92 billion barrels of oil reserves and a sovereign-wealth fund with probably over $300 billion of assets. The consolidated balance-sheet of the UAE is not overly stretched. It is just that one emirate has most of the assets; its neighbour has most of the liabilities.